Chef-made · Small batch · Est. 2021

Fermented pepper sauce with a chef’s palate

Four small-batch hot sauces built on fresh peppers, real fruit, and slow fermentation. No dyes, no fake flavorings, nothing watery. Just flavor first, then heat.

Meet the saucesShop online
1st 2025 Amaru Dragon Award · Best Peruvian Pepper Sauce, Sweet Heat
The Benny Sauce lineup: Original, Verde, Sweet, and Diablo Heat bottles surrounded by fresh peppers and fruit
MADE IN CHARLOTTENORTH CAROLINABENNYSAUCE
Fermented & shelf-stable · 2-year shelf lifeNo dyes · No added flavorings5 oz woozy bottleHundreds of orders shipped nationwide
The Lineup

Four sauces, four moods

Every bottle starts with fresh peppers and a slow ferment. Pick your heat, or grab the four-pack and stop choosing.

Verde Heat bottle

Verde Heat

Mild

A play on the classic green sauce: charred tomatillo, garlic, onion, lime, and jalapeño. All the flavor, easy on the fire.

EggsBurritosChimichurriMarinades
$8.99per bottle
Buy
Original Heat bottle

Original Heat

Medium

The accident that started it all. Aged fresno, serrano, and habanero with dried apricot. Not too hot, not too mild, always on the table.

TacosPizzaOystersBloody Marys
$8.99per bottle
Buy
Sweet Heat bottle

Sweet Heat

Medium

The award winner. Passion fruit, agave, chile manzano, carrots, and aji amarillo. Tropical, grassy, built for lighter dishes.

SeafoodChickenGlazesSpicy Margs
$10.99per bottle
Buy
Diablo Heat bottle

Diablo Heat

Hot

The evil sibling. Fresh peppers, black garlic, and truffle. Flavor first, then a whole other level of heat. Less is more.

WingsDipping SaucesPimento Cheese
$10.99per bottle
Buy
Benny Sauce Collector's Gift Box with all four sauces and stickers
Cook With Benny

What to put it on

Straight from Ben’s kitchen. Full recipes live on the site and the Benny Sauce YouTube channel.

Grilled steak topped with Benny chimichurri

Steak & Benny Chimichurri

Verde Heat

Grilled picanha with a Verde-based chimichurri. Works on any protein.

Shrimp cocktail with spicy sauce

Shrimp Cocktail

Original Heat

Party-ready cocktail sauce with a fermented kick.

Spicy mango daiquiri with chili rim

Spicy Mango Daiquiri

Sweet Heat

Poolside heat. Sweet Heat in a frozen drink with a chili-salt rim.

Chicken salad crostini appetizers

Crostini Fix

Diablo Heat

Bite-sized appetizers with a drop of Diablo on top. Less is more.

Ben Reardon in chef whites
Mark and Kelly Reardon
Who We Are

Founded by accident.
Perfected on purpose.

Benny Sauce started in a Charlotte kitchen in 2021, when chef Ben Reardon’s pepper experiment fermented its way into something too good to keep to himself. With 17 years of restaurant and catering experience, Ben builds each sauce like a dish: balanced, layered, and made to make food better.

It’s a family operation. Mark runs sales and business development, Kelly keeps the brand and the books straight, and Ben keeps the burners on.

2021Founded in Charlotte
17 yrsChef experience
4Sauces & counting
Where To Find

On shelves & on the road

Order online anytime, or catch Benny Sauce in person at shows across the Carolinas and Georgia.

Ace Hardware

In store at two Ohio locations.

Kent: 176 Cherry St, Kent, OH 44240
Akron: 1592 W Market St, Akron, OH 44313

The Peach Stand

Fort Mill's gourmet grocery institution since 1980.

Fort Mill: 1325 South Carolina 160, Fort Mill, SC 29715

Online & In Person

Shipped nationwide from bennythings.com, plus eBay and Google Marketplace.

Live events: markets & shows across North Carolina and Georgia

Good To Know

Frequently asked

How hot are we talking?

Flavor leads, heat follows. Verde is the gentle one, Original and Sweet sit comfortably in the middle, and Diablo is for people who mean it.

Why no dispensing cap?

A shaker cap would leave all the good stuff behind. Benny Sauce is thick with real ingredients, so it pours instead. Just watch your pour!

Is it shelf stable?

Yes. Each 5 oz woozy bottle is fermented, finished with a kill step, and holds a 2-year shelf life.

What's actually in it?

Peppers, fruit, and aromatics. No dyes or added flavorings. The only “preservatives” are citric acid for freshness and xanthan gum for stability.

Join Benny Things

10% off your first order

Sauce drops, new stockists, and recipes from Ben’s kitchen. No spam, just heat.

Sign up at the store